Home / Comments and Opinions / The Dismissal of Šuker and Milinović Would Be a Great Service

The Dismissal of Šuker and Milinović Would Be a Great Service

Croatia is facing an extended recession in 2011. Therefore, the dismissed ministers could claim in a year or two that things were stable during their time, and when they had to leave – the state finances began to collapse.

Written by: Miodrag Šajatović
[email protected]

A weaker credit rating, warnings from abroad, foreign exchange interventions… these are minor tremors that very likely herald a more devastating shock in the national economy

The delayed moves of the HDZ continue. The party whose ministers were two years late in acknowledging that Croatia is in recession is now, with at least two years of delay, embarking on a government reconstruction. In globally dangerous times, a delay of several months is dramatic. Years of delay is equivalent to catastrophe. If it is true that ‘on the chopping block’ are Finance Minister Ivan Šuker and Health Minister, but more importantly, HDZ Vice President Darko Milinović, and that in addition to replacements for them, a new Deputy Prime Minister for Economy is being sought, one might think that things will start to change for the better after the dismissals. However, it is quite clear that changes ahead of a long electoral race will not help improve the economic and business climate in the country.
It may even happen that the formal losers Šuker and Milinović will be happy in the medium term that they had to leave. It is quite possible that the shaky state finances will collapse in 2011. The manifestation of the collapse that Šuker’s successor would face would be delays in public sector salaries and pensions. Thus, Šuker could score points by saying that while he was taking care of the state treasury, salaries and pensions were arriving on time.

Without a New Model What has been destroyed in his seven years is the foundation from which taxes for salaries and pensions are collected and that borrowing was done without measure and at usurious interest rates, the public with a short memory would not take into account. There would surely be those who would lament for ‘Šuker’s times’.
When it comes to Darko Milinović, at first glance, his candidacy to succeed Jadranka Kosor appears to be political suicide. But if the HDZ loses, and he is dismissed from his ministerial position beforehand, here he is after the parliamentary elections as someone who wanted to save the situation, but Kosor and Šeks did not allow him. It is completely irrelevant who from the ruling political nomenclature will sit in ministerial chairs until the elections. Even if everything were not already subordinated to desperate moves to gather voters, this government is naturally untalented for conducting economic policy. It must also be acknowledged that among the economic thinkers close to the government, there is no one with proposals that would truly be a new economic model applicable to today’s Croatian circumstances.
This was also shown by the conference well organized by colleagues from Poslovni dnevnik and the Bank. They brought numerous prominent economic names. There were many partial ideas, but once again it was shown that there are unfortunately no geniuses who would come up with proposals that would leave the public stunned in Croatia today. The highlight was the accurate diagnosis by Prof. Dr. Ivo Bićanić about the need for shock therapy. But when it was attempted to explain what it should be like – it ended up in generalities.

Ignoring Minor Tremors And in the so-called real economy, the situation is dramatic. Analysts are disappointed that industrial production is falling at a rate greater than four percent despite contrary expectations. Only salon economists, who have not a single day of experience in a company and in a place where one needs to earn a salary in the market (and not live off a budget-secured salary), can believe that GDP will grow in Croatia next year. Salon economists cannot incorporate into their models what entrepreneurs and managers in Croatia have learned in the last two years. Many businessmen in 2008 and 2009 believed politicians and some analysts that the crisis was just about to pass. So they postponed adjustments to a prolonged recession. They did not cut costs enough, produced for warehouses, took expensive working loans. But they painfully learned the lesson. Now most are very cautious. They have pulled the handbrake and it is difficult to entice them into investments and development with cheap tricks and announcements.

In the market jungle, there is a struggle for mere survival. Many are on the brink of business failure and will not be able to fill the budget as the government envisioned.
It is true, there are still no major tremors. There is electricity, there are goods in stores, there are no lines in front of banks, there are no protests… But minor tremors are becoming more frequent. They often represent a precursor to a devastating shock. But there is no reaction to this. The country’s credit rating deteriorates. Well, it doesn’t matter! Rohatinski announces the collapse of the current economic model within a year. Well, it doesn’t matter! The HNB starts spending foreign exchange reserves to defend the kuna from weakening. Well, it doesn’t matter! Five hundred new bankruptcies open in a few months. Well, it doesn’t matter… If these signals are ignored, a lesson on prolonged recession will come.