Home / Media and Publications / Has the worst passed?

Has the worst passed?

A series of slightly less bad economic news has been arriving from the world’s leading economies in recent days, which analysts currently attribute more to the healing abilities of governments and central banks than to the actual health of those economies, and they believe it is still too early to conclude that the worst has passed.

New indicators of activity in the industrial and service sectors around the world last week were slightly better, and there were also signs of stabilization in the U.S. real estate market, leading some economists and investors to conclude that the worst may have passed. However, a somewhat more detailed look at the state of the global economy suggests that the private sector still appears quite sick and that this quarter could be just as bad as the previous one. Public spending, as well as promises to intensify it, currently only help the global economy. The credit programs of the U.S. Fed have managed to lower mortgage rates, protected the money market from collapse, and revived some parts of the commercial credit market. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke will be able to boast about this progress at a meeting with leaders of the Group of Seven (G7) this Friday in Rome. However, he will not bring them cheerful economic messages.

Namely, personal consumption in the U.S. has sharply fallen, as has that in most European countries and Japan. Business spending is cautious at best. Unemployment is rising. Given such a grim picture, banks continue to hesitate significantly with lending, and taxpayer money is being rapidly spent. There will be plenty of talk about this throughout the week. Specifically, the Bank of England will launch a program to purchase commercial paper from British companies, the U.S. Congress is likely to adopt an economic stimulus package worth between $800 and $900 billion, and U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner will present ideas on how best to address the situation in the struggling banking sector.

France is expected to announce a support plan for the struggling automotive sector today, as both Renault and PSA Peugeot Citroen are announcing weak business results for 2008. Chief economist at Capital Economics, Jonathan Loynes, considers the fact that the Bank of England plans to bypass banks and directly lend to companies as perhaps “the first acknowledgment that banking operations will not normalize in the foreseeable future.” The same applies to banks in the U.S. President Barack Obama and his economic advisors realize they must urgently take action to put financial companies on stronger foundations and stimulate lending.

The primary goal of all government interventions is to shorten the duration of the recession and revive growth. The question is how much governments and central banks are willing to spend to achieve this and whether it will be enough to fill the growing gap between actual and potential GDP. “We are in the midst of a great experiment. Can the largest monetary and fiscal stimuli in modern times overcome the greatest economic and financial crisis? If we weren’t laboratory rats, we would enjoy all of this,” says economist Ethan Harris from Barclays Capital. In the stock markets last week, investors tended to conclude that some bad news had already been priced into stocks, so stock indices recorded gains in anticipation of better times. However, it is still too early to conclude that the last quarter of last year was the peak of the recession cycle, analysts warn.

“Despite growing investor optimism that the global economy has reached the bottom of the cycle, indicators remain catastrophically bad,” says strategist at Societe Generale, Albert Edwards. This week, the announcement of GDP data for the Eurozone in the last quarter of last year is expected, which is projected to show a GDP decline of 1.1 percent year-on-year. And while new news from the U.S. regarding the adoption of the economic stimulus package in the U.S. Senate is awaited, this morning the MSCI World Index has slightly weakened. However, the MSCI Emerging Markets Index continued to rise for the fifth consecutive day, by 0.4 percent, reflecting a gradual return of investor appetite for risk. Since the beginning of the year, this index is down only 1.3 percent, outperforming the MSCI World Index, which is still down 5.4 percent. (H)