Home / Media and Publications / The World Economic Forum in Davos Offered Neither Solutions Nor New Ideas

The World Economic Forum in Davos Offered Neither Solutions Nor New Ideas

The call to avoid a return to protectionism, the focus on the USA and the new administration, fear of social unrest, calls for multilateralism and unity, and the establishment of a financial system with new rules are the messages of this year’s Forum.

Written by: Vanja Figenwald
[email protected]

Another World Economic Forum in Davos has concluded without shaking the world. Despite the always very good image of attendees, from prime ministers and presidents to business heavyweights and NGOs, to the poor protesters outside, as usual, the Forum did not produce conclusions that could not have been written in the summary before it began. In summary, the messages could be arranged as follows: a call to avoid a return to protectionism, a focus on the USA and the new administration, fear of social unrest if things drag on, calls for multilateralism and unity, and a call to re-establish the financial system with new rules. Some of it is a statement of the obvious, some is part of folklore, and some is an adaptation to recent events. All in all, without any direct set of measures or some revolutionary new ideas, in a word – expected.

The theme of protectionism ranked quite high this year due to the growing fear among many actors in the global economy that the crisis is leading to a significant expansion of the definition of permissible protectionism compared to happier times. Fears were further heightened by recent measures from some countries, notably the USA, which unpleasantly smell of economic closure, or the strengthening of introversion in economic behavior. Thus, we have reached an absurdity that is not really an absurdity, where the German Chancellor and the Russian Prime Minister are teaching the owner of the definition of capitalism – America – the rules of the market economy and reading lessons on the freedom of capital, services, and labor flow.

The next thing Davos revealed is the persistent focus, primarily of the West, on America and the expectation that everything will be great once they sort things out over there. This reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of historical changes and an inability to read history. Production first left America, and now money is following. Elements of global influence seem to be slowly and irreversibly leaking from American hands. Besides, it has been clear for some time that ‘some new kids’ are taking on new roles in the world order, and in Davos, one could notice the strengthening voice of developing countries, primarily China and Russia. In this sense, it is understandable that there is an increasingly strong turn towards the G20 concept, an expanded circle of the wealthiest and largest economies in the world. Suddenly, the West is very eager to cooperate, and quickly.

Interest in regulation and control

Social unrest is a sort of dark horse of the Forum, an uncomfortable truth that has not yet become a serious threat, but could easily and very quickly become a winning topic if things do not urgently improve, especially if they worsen. Protests in Davos were again part of the usual folklore this year, although on a smaller scale than usual. However, this is quite irrelevant as it was mostly about often idle and better-off salon anarchists, alter-globalists, and left-right organizations. They are disorganized and lack a unified program and voice. The real danger lies in riots within national frameworks, where there are clear structures, divisions of power, organized unions, and groups with very clear goals. This was quite clear to the distinguished guests. Add accumulated anger, director and manager bonuses, mix in direct dissatisfaction with possible job loss or poverty, and you have an explosive mass.

Calls for multilateralism, this time complemented by a sudden interest in regulation and control, are part of the classic, immortal scenario that regularly repeats in one form or another in Davos. This year, realizing that the devil has taken the joke, humbled Westerners began to seriously call for closer cooperation, multilateralism, global agreements, brotherhood, and new unity in addressing the crisis. There was a lot of love felt in Davos these days.

Rebuilding the financial system, acting locally on a global scale, is a call that belongs to the category of stating the obvious. The system has collapsed, so it is quite obvious that it needs to be rebuilt. It collapsed because it was extremely poor, so it needs to be made on different principles. What and how remains a mystery, although it can be discerned that there will be greater control over unruly corporates, stronger regulation, greater cooperation among states on this issue, etc…

Scandal in Davos

Davos shot its best moments this year at the beginning, in the first two days. First, Russian Prime Minister Putin and Chinese Wen Jiabao fired a solid salvo at the culprits for the crisis – the Americans, only to later call for cooperation in a conciliatory manner. The dust was stirred by Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan, who demonstratively left the discussion on the Middle East, provoked by the heartfelt performance of Israeli Prime Minister Peres, to whom he could not respond. The situation was later further heated by the contender for the position of the new Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, claiming that the Iranian nuclear threat is the world’s biggest problem, not some economic crisis. Iran, on the other hand, was in a gentle edition, calling on the new American administration for cooperation in the region. The old foxes from Wall Street, the crew responsible for the whole mess, predictably did not appear at the Forum in particularly large numbers, probably due to new austerity measures. Or perhaps it was assessed that they would not feel good there, especially when some attendees openly and seriously called for their criminal prosecution, often by their colleagues, business captains.

The World Economic Forum in Davos has always had a consulting-philosophical role, a place where many smart and relevant people gather to discuss current issues and make principled statements. The real value, of course, does not lie in the messages and measures that Davos can produce, but in the informal contacts of world leaders, whose handshakes everyone else feels on their skin somewhat later. Reports unanimously indicated the impossibility of finding solutions to the crisis, which was, after all, the theme of the meeting, adding that participants were unable to even measure its depth, let alone find constructive answers.